A Kauffman Foundation site

RSS Feed Link

Entrepreneurship Rhetoric vs. Action in Washington

Posted by: Mark Marich on September 13, 2010 Source: Policy Dialogue on Entrepreneurship

Venturebeat.com had an interesting guest column last week by Jeff Bussgang, a General Partner at Flybridge Capital Partners.  In “Who will champion entrepreneurship in Washington?” Bussgang reflects on President Obama’s speech on Iraq, where he declared that “Our most urgent task is to restore our economy and put the millions of Americans who have lost their jobs back to work…We must unleash…innovation…and nurture the ideas the spring from our entrepreneurs.” The writer then points out that despite the obvious data and the presidential rhetoric, we are not seeing policymakers pushing legislation forward.


So here’s what I don’t understand. If everyone, including the president, believes that supporting innovation and entrepreneurship is the best path forward, why aren’t the policy leaders taking action?  Thomas Friedman of the NY Times has been hammering on this issue for the last year, calling on the president to “launch his own moon shot” and make innovation and supporting the start-up economy his top priority.

First, let’s review the data.  The Kauffman Foundation did  a comprehensive study of historical job creation and, not surprisingly, found that small businesses are the main source.  “Without startups,” writes Senior Fellow Tim Kane, there would be no net job growth in the US economy.  This fact is true on average, but also true for all but seven years for which the US has data going back to 1977.”


It’s worth reading the article in its entirety. It outlines some policy ideas that have been proposed lately but are stagnating due to a lack of leadership, such as making it easier for immigrants to start companies in the US, an idea backed by the Start-Up Visa movement.


The amazing thing to me is that none of these ideas – and many others floating around the entrepreneurial community – require big dollars.  Instead, they require big leadership.  Where is that leadership going to come from?  Who will be our champion for entrepreneurship? Ted Kennedy played this role in health care. Who will step up and be the champion for entrepreneurs?


The author proposes a few other ideas, such as creating a special Bipartisan Commission on Entrepreneurship, and changing the president’s lunch list to include leading thinkers in entrepreneurship and innovation.  

What are your ideas for championing entrepreneurship in Washington?

Category:  General  Growth & Poverty 

1 Comments

RE: Entrepreneurship Rhetoric vs Action in Washington
September 14, 2010 @ 11:39 AM
Jeff said...
The problem with Washington is that there’s been too much of the wrong kind of action that’s unfavorable to an entrepreneurial climate. If Thomas Friedman thinks that President Obama will abandon his Keynesian ideology to push favorable legislation for entrepreneurship, he may be waiting for quite awhile. Obama’s plan to serve up higher taxes to businesses employing between 20-299 workers (over 25% of the workforce) will do nothing more than set back job creation and investment in innovation.

Morris notes, “President Obama has had a series of CEO lunches at the White House. When you examine the list of invitees, it is shocking how few are entrepreneurs. I counted two (Jeff Bezos and Howard Schultz) among 28.” This tells us a lot about how little President Obama knows about economics and job creation.

If the federal government really wants to spur innovation, they need to create a better climate for it to flourish. They should start with taxes and regulation. In regards to taxes, how about a substantial cut in the payroll tax? How about cutting the second highest corporate tax rate in the developing world? How about getting spending under control?

All of these measures would give the economy what it really needs – a jolt of confidence and stability first, and motivation to invest capital in job creation secondly. The uncertainty created by pending regulation, higher taxes and increased healthcare costs is paralyzing in and of itself. There doesn’t seem to be a coherent plan from the top down.

Regarding regulation, many small business owners can relate to the overwhelming strain of complying with IRS and EPA regulations while having to comply with very costly Sarbanes-Oxley regulations with fewer resources to do so than larger firms. It’s an unfair penalty on small business.

Friedman makes some good points, explaining, “If we want to bring down unemployment in a sustainable way, neither rescuing General Motors nor funding more road construction will do it. We need to create a big bushel of new companies — fast.” Exactly.

Unfortunately, the Keynesian brand of questionable economic policies coming out of Washington has diminished the previously attractive entrepreneurial environment from one that rewards hard work and innovation to one that rewards failed car companies and values temporary work over permanent growth.

Friedman concludes, “The best way to counter the Tea Party movement, which is all about stopping things, is with an Innovation Movement, which is all about starting things.” I would be very much in favor of the Innovation Movement and starting things. We need a lot more of that in the U.S. But Friedman wastes a nice thought with his unnecessary and divisive remark about the Tea Party.

We will have to all work together at the grass roots level to rejuvenate the job creating machine that is the American economy. We need to pressure our political leaders and hold them accountable for their economic policies, stressing the need for entrepreneurial tax and regulatory reform that transcend party politics and boost innovation and permanent job growth. If what’s being done at the present isn’t working, and hasn’t worked for the past 3-4 years, we need to look for smart alternatives this coming November.

Add a Comment

Search PDE

Policy Dialogue on Entrepreneurship Get Your Weekly Digest

Register today to receive news and updates from Entrepreneurship.org.

Email Newsletter Signup