A Kauffman Foundation site

RSS Feed Link

Part One: Is entrepreneurship education an oxymoron?

Posted by: Anonymous on July 15, 2010 Source: e360 Blog

This is the first in a two part series in which Gary Schoeniger discusses entrepreneurship education. Below is Part One: Is entrepreneurship education an oxymoron?

Are entrepreneurs born with a unique ability?

What is it that enables them to recognize opportunities that the rest of us overlook? And how are they able to accomplish so much with so little?

Once looked upon as Mavericks who bucked the system, entrepreneurs have become mainstream players who are now driving innovation, new job creation and economic growth.

Yet, while much is known about small business management and the inner workings of large organizations; surprisingly little is known about entrepreneurs and their ability to create new ventures.

For much of the last century, entrepreneurs were largely ignored; their decision making process was once characterized as, “a scientifically unfathomable mystery.” Large organizations fostered a hierarchical culture steeped in scientific management theories and narrowly defined job descriptions that focused on repetition and efficiency rather than innovation and entrepreneurship. The promise of job security and a decent wage rendered entrepreneurship virtually irrelevant as a subject of interest or field of study.

Today, entrepreneurs have become the force multipliers of our economy, yet the term entrepreneurship education has become somewhat of an oxymoron. Many of these emerging academic and government sponsored initiatives have adopted a formulaic approach that reflects this old-economy mindset – making little or no distinction between entrepreneurship and small business management. By doing so, they often overlook what may be the most essential aspects of entrepreneurship and what it really takes to start and grow a successful new venture. Not surprisingly, the results have been limited and for many, the “secret” to entrepreneurial success remains a mystery.


 

  • 1

5 Comments

Re: Part One Is entrepreneurship education an oxymoron
July 31, 2010 @ 12:00 AM
Trish Truitt said...
It is still a mystery but I know of folks who are starting to put some of the pieces together.
Yes there definitely are institutions that are slapping an entrepreneurship label onto rote SBM curriculum and saying ‘we got it!’ And of course they don’t.

But then you find truly innovative and dynamic programs such as the Community College Entrepreneurial Pathway project in Fresno CA or what Cayuga Community College, in New York is doing.

http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2010/03/29/cayuga

OK call me prejudiced ( I work for NACCE) But I think the root of the issue is that universities have always been very theoretical by nature. Whereas 2-year institutions (and especially technical colleges) are more focused on the experiential component.

Entrepreneurship is a hands-on, get your feet wet, kind of endeavor. It comes in lots of different flavors, styles and intensities. It can scale from gnat size to behemoth and it seems to come out of nowhere. So of course it’s been hard to tag and bag.

By and large through, community colleges - when properly funded and supported - have the innate flexibility to deal with that level of variance. You can go for a traditional 2-year entrepreneurship or business degree and transfer to a traditional 4-year program OR you can take a more vocationally oriented program with a strong entrepreneurship component OR you can take a 9-12 week non-credit course like FastTrack OR you can take spot courses to fill in your knowledge gaps OR just attend ongoing outreach seminars offered by many community colleges to serve their current small business communities.

The problem isn’t academia it’s where it all starts and where all the funding has been focused – on the most theoretical of learning institutions.

The questions we need to look at are elemental: Do they thrive? Do they survive?
Experience and application count more than any grade point average. Because in the end, the final mark isn’t given by any institution – but rather by the market.

Re: Part One Is entrepreneurship education an oxymoron
July 31, 2010 @ 12:00 AM
topsy.com said...
Pingback from topsy.com

Twitter Trackbacks for

Entrepreneurship.org e360 Blog | Part One: Is entrepreneurship education an oxymoron?
[entrepreneurship.org]
on Topsy.com
Re: Part One Is entrepreneurship education an oxymoron
July 31, 2010 @ 12:00 AM
Kathy said...
In my opinion, entrepreneurship isn't really teachable in standard academia unless it is being taught by former entrepreneurs.

Very few people who have studied business management and very few who have worked in the corporate world will ever make successful entrepreneurs. There has to be a willingness to look at things for what they are in practical terms rather than analyzing things from some kind of higher level knowledge.

Most people who start their own businesses don't do it because they have discovered some unmet need in the marketplace. Most people do it because they want to run their own business. They choose a business to launch not necessarily based on the market demand for that business, but rather their own personal understanding of how to perform the day to day functions of that business. That is why you see so many copycat businesses and why so many fail at it.
Re: Part One Is entrepreneurship education an oxymoron
July 31, 2010 @ 12:00 AM
gemslewis said...
I believe embracing entrepreneurship will enable nations to make a quantum leap from despair to prosperity. The survey findings cannot be generalized to all schools in the USA, although there are no other samples of this size. Entrepreneurship is a fundamentally part of our current economic transformation. Let the creativity that is so much a part of entrepreneurship do its work.
RE: Part One Is entrepreneurship education an oxymoron
September 01, 2010 @ 09:59 PM
indirmedenizle.org said...
Hi .. The survey findings cannot be generalized to all schools in the USA, although there are no other samples of this size. Entrepreneurship is a fundamentally part of our current economic transformation. Let the creativity that is so much a part of entrepreneurship do its work.

Add a Comment