What to Expect From Angel Networks
William H. (Bill) Payne, Senior Program Consultant, Kauffman Foundation
Ten years ago, access to individuals who invest in early-stage companies - commonly called "angel" investors - was hard to come by for entrepreneurs seeking such financing. These days, however, the angel investing landscape has changed. As angel investors increasingly pool their funds or connect in networks, they are becoming more accessible.
That is good news for today's company builders. The bad news, however, is that the process of securing such funding remains as tedious and as inefficient as it always has been.
I should know. I was an entrepreneur myself, having been involved in the launch of a half dozen businesses, including Solid State Dielectrics, Inc. which I started with a partner in 1971 and sold 11 years later to E. I. DuPont Nemours. Since then, I've become an angel investor, having put money into some 25 fledgling ventures. In short, I know the ins and outs of dealing with angels from both sides of the table.
A Different Landscape
For today's entrepreneurs, the different landscape provides opportunities that might not have existed in the past. While "angel" investors - exited entrepreneurs and experienced business people who have the TIME and MONEY to put into early-stage companies - have always been a part of the entrepreneurial scene, they are now breaking down into sub-categories. Some, called "lone rangers," prefer to invest alone or with a small informal group.
Others, namely "angel funds," pool their resources and invest collectively, in a sort of "one for all, all for one" approach determined by a vote of the majority. Finally, there are the "angel networks," whose members study companies as a group and consult among themselves about attractive opportunities but make individual investment decisions. Usually, only a fraction of the total network invests in any one company.
As an angel investor, I have been involved in all of these formats. However, I prefer operating as part of a network for two reasons. The first is that I like to pick and chose the companies in which I put my money while at the same time benefiting from access to the perspective of like-minded colleagues. Secondly, and as importantly, I've found that angels linked in networks are likely to take an active role in the companies in which they invest, as opposed to becoming passive investors, as is often the case with investors utilizing pooled funds.
Some Things Never Change
Similarly, angel networks work well for entrepreneurs, and not only because of their accessibility. Before I delve into the reasons, however, let me start with a primer about when company founders should seek angel financing. The key is that the company shouldn't be too young. Funding for the start up still at the kitchen table - called "pre-seed" money - is the province of an entrepreneur's family and friends, and, undoubtedly, his or her personal resources.
Angel financing, on the other hand, comes into the picture when the entrepreneur has a management team in place, or has team members waiting in the wings; a product ready for the marketplace, or a least a prototype that can be demonstrated to customers; and finally, customers or potential customers who have expressed interest in buying the product.
Angel investors are looking to invest in companies with the potential to grow to at least $30 million, and preferably much more. Why? Angel investing is a risky business. These investors must be assured of a return of, say, 25 percent to 30 percent a year. At the same time, they have calculated that nine out of every 10 investments they make will fail. The one company that makes it, therefore, needs to be a wild success.
If only one investment out of 10 is expected to be a winner - and the investor doesn't know which it will be - then it follows that each investment must have the potential to provide a huge return on the investment to achieve the expected angel portfolio upside. (My own rule of thumb is that each angel investment must have the potential to provide a 30 times ROI in five years.) In angel circles, this means that "scalable equals fundable," a maxim about angel financing that entrepreneurs need to keep uppermost in their minds when approaching angels.
Finding Angel Networks
OK, you qualify, so now what? First, zero in on the angel networks, which got their start in the mid 1990s and are much more accessible than individuals. Formerly, finding angels was a matter of "trial by fire." These individuals hid from entrepreneurs because they only wanted to engage with a small number of companies each year.
These days, angel networks are easy to find, with their information prominently displayed on Web sites. Some have affinity links to particular types of entrepreneurs, such as women or African-Americans. Better yet, most tend to invest in companies located within an hour's drive of their headquarters, so founders can work the local community and approach them personally.
Contacts can also be made through knowledgeable professionals, such as local accountants and bankers who serve young companies, other entrepreneurs, venture clubs, or even the technology-transfer centers at research universities.
Walking the Talk
When approaching angel networks, understand that there is a process by which the investors decide which investments to make. Entrepreneurs need to familiarize themselves with the process, which for most angel networks breaks down along the following lines:
Application - Angel investors know exactly what documents they want to review at the initial stage (and it is not likely a 60-page business plan, at least not initially.) Now that networks have formed, a list of this information is readily available on Web sites or from the gatekeeper of the local group. Be scrupulous about assembling just what the group wants on the application form, a process that generally takes applicants a week or two to complete.
Pre-Screening - When the angel group gets a completed application, one or two of its staff or members takes a quick look at the all of the plans received and returns applications that are incomplete, don't meet the organization's minimum requirements, or do not comply with the investing preferences of the organization. Expect one or two weeks for the pre-screening process to run its course.
Screening - Once an application has been accepted for more review, a small group of staff and angels who are members of the network meet with the entrepreneur to review and further define the opportunity. If the entrepreneur passes muster at this stage, the network selects a "champion" for the opportunity, creates a committee and begins due diligence. In general, only 10 percent to 25 percent of all entrepreneurs who apply reach this stage, which is usually completed within another one to three weeks.
Due Diligence - At the critical due diligence phase, a team from the network is assembled, consisting of members interested in investing and specialists with knowledge of the industry under consideration. The objective is to validate the business plan, including the management team, market opportunity and amount of funding required, and to negotiate a term sheet, thus placing a value on the investment. A further cut is made: only 10 percent to 20 percent of the companies that reach this stage are actually funded, and the process can continue for a little as two weeks or as many as three months.
Investment Meeting - Once the network has negotiated a term sheet, the entrepreneur is invited to make his or her pitch at an investment meeting of all members of the angel organization. Commonly, the leader of the due diligence team introduces the entrepreneur; a question-and-answer session follows the founder's presentation; and members are invited to sign up for subsequent meeting with the entrepreneur. Such investment meetings are usually held every month or two.
The Final Cut
With a process from application to investment that is seldom less than three months and often as many as six, the flourishing of angel networks has hardly stripped away all of the tedium and pain involved in securing such financing. But the much greater accessibility afforded by the gathering of angels into networks has smoothed the way for today's entrepreneurs.
The lucky few that make the final cut, moreover, gain much more than funding. They get an accessible group of knowledgeable business people who are eager to take an advisory role in the company, sit on the board of directors, or serve as informal mentors. That, too, can be a blessing and a curse, say the company founders who have availed themselves of financing from angel networks. But that's another story.